Two, Two, Two Book Reviews in One
Other People's Dirt: A Housecleaners Curious Adventures
by Louise Rafkin
Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill, 1998
Are those piles of old mail, monster dust bunnies, clothes from high school and useless kitchen gadgets revealing a lack of control in your life?  In Other People's Dirt, Louise Rafkin claims they do indeed, and furthermore, you neatniks are just the other side of this same control-freak coin.  With humor and insight she tackles a subject we all have to deal with sooner or later - dirt.  Like my favorite childhood hero, Harriet the Spy, Louise started out peering into her neighbors' windows, notebook in hand, and making up stories about them.  When she grew up, through serendipity or bad luck, she became a housecleaner.  This seems to be an excellent day job for a writer: good pay, ample opportunity for sleuthing, and interesting material to write about.  From the 12- stepping Messies Anonymous to nude housecleaning services, she explores her subject with a sharp eye for weird detail.  At times she takes easy potshots at her "upper, upper class X-ray thin" customers, but also reveals her own awkward class differences with Lupita, her childhood housekeeper.

Other People's Dirt will make you chuckle and perhaps look harder at your attitude toward housecleaners and housecleaning.  You might even discover, as the author did, that scrubbing toilets can be a spiritual path.

BOTTOM LINE: Smart and amusing.

Cupid and Diana
by Christina Bartolomeo 
Scribner, 1998 
Have you noticed how, on the East coast, people talk about their family heritage more than they do in the West?  They're interested in the background of your last name - "Hey, my wife is Italian too, on her mother's side," or "What is that, Armenian?"  There is a consciousness about history and ethnic flavor.  This was something I enjoyed about Cupid and Diana.  The main character, Diana, is from an Italian Catholic family, and lives in a middle class Washington, D.C., neighborhood.  She's about 30 and is involved with two very different men: the blue-blooded son of a southern senator, and a sweet but rumpled Jewish guy from New York.  She has to make a choice and it challenges much of what she understands about herself.  We follow her story as she struggles with her business (a vintage clothing store that is about to fold) and her tense family dynamics.  She runs interference between one glamorous sister who models lingerie; the other sister, a frumpy conservative housewife; and the irritating dad who plays favorites.  How she finds her own way is a little too pat, but has charm.

This is Christina Bartolomeo's first novel and it appears semi autobiographical.  The writing is light (but happily not 'lite') and chatty.  She's written for Cosmopolitan and it shows.  Imagine a romantic comedy starring a brunette Meg Ryan, or maybe Courtney Cox.  Hugh Grant and John Stewart could be cast as the love interests.

BOTTOM LINE: Enjoyable but no surprises.

--Jennifer Murphy
 Table of Contents
 Flip back
 
© 1999 MASH magazine, All Rights Reserved.